For mixture, we don't care a bit what colour the metal parts of
the plug are. Glazing and fouling and some other problems show up
there, but not mixture. White is just as good as tan is just as
good as grey. Bare metal colour is best. If there is unburned gas
left over in the mix (meaning it's too rich, by (definition), you
get soot on the centre ceramic insulator. Soot is black, period.
If it's very rich, the whole insulator will be sooty. If it's somewhat
rich, the tip will be clean and the soot will start partway down
the insulator. The best power point is when the soot just barely
doesn't appear all the way down to the base of the insulator.
If the mixture is leaner than that, there's no visible change.
In other words, you cannot detect leanness from reading plugs, only
richness. Often the insulator will turn light grey or violet, or
even orange. Those are deposits from salts in the fuel. The colour
doesn't tell you anything useful. If there's a white ring around
the tip of the insulator where the salts are blasted away, the timing
is too advanced. If there is no white ring at all, the timing is
retarded. You want about a millimetre or white around the electrode.
A streak down one side of the insulator from the spark is normal
-- look for a ring that goes all the way around.
Black speckles on the insulator are from pinging, whether you heard
it or not. If the tip of the insulator looks crumbly and porous,
the heat range is too hot. If the whole plug looks dark rather than
a pastel shade, it's too cold. You can tell a whole lot about an
engine's state of tune from reading plugs correctly, but not from
colour in particular.
Dave's notes: Phil is the editor of VClassics magazine, devoted
to older
(Round fendered) Volvos. He is a racer, and an engine builder who
regularly
gets 250+ hp out of a 2 litre Volvo pushrod 4 cyl, and is often
called upon
to do road tests for more mainstream car magazines. I contacted
him to get permission to run this.